Itzy Ritzy
Itzy Ritzy's pacifiers are the affordable, widely-stocked take on the popular round-nipple style. The Sweetie Soother silicone version is 100% food-grade silicone; the natural-rubber version uses a German natural-rubber nipple mounted in a BPA-free hard-plastic shield and handle. Neither is fully plastic-free: the silicone one is silicone-only, and the rubber one puts a plastic shield against the baby's face. A one-piece natural-rubber pacifier avoids both.
How clear are their specs?
States the silicone paci is 100% food-grade silicone, and that the rubber version's nipple is natural rubber while the shield and handle are BPA-free plastic - materials are named clearly.
Products to avoid
Documented so you know what to skip — each still has a full breakdown and sources.