Best Plastic-Free Teethers & Pacifiers
Pacifiers and teething toys - the things babies have in their mouths the most.
Why plastic matters here
Nothing spends more time in a baby's mouth than a pacifier or teether, often for hours a day, chewed hard, during the period when they're most vulnerable to chemical exposure. Most mainstream pacifiers are plastic shields with silicone nipples, and many teethers are plastic or water-filled plastic. This is the clearest place the natural-rubber-versus-silicone choice matters, so it's a core plastic-free question for parents.
What to look for
- One-piece natural rubber pacifiers (Natursutten, Hevea) are the fully plastic-free and silicone-free option
- Silicone-nipple pacifiers are common and accepted by many, but the shield is usually plastic
- Teethers - natural rubber or untreated wood are plastic-free; avoid water/gel-filled plastic teethers
- Latex allergy is the one caveat with natural rubber
Our picks
The benchmark: one molded piece of 100% natural rubber - nipple, shield, and button all the same material - with no plastic ring, no plastic shield, and no silicone anywhere. Being one piece, there are no joints to trap bacteria. Made in Italy by a long-established rubber maker. The strictest choice for parents avoiding both plastic and silicone; the only caveat is the latex-allergy risk of any natural rubber.
HEVEA's take on the same idea - a seamless one-piece 100% natural rubber pacifier, here with star- and moon-shaped vent holes and a butterfly shield. Fully plastic-free and silicone-free, meets US and EU pacifier standards, and usually a couple of dollars cheaper than the Natursutten. Pick between the two on nipple shape and availability; both are the real plastic-free deal.
A one-piece natural rubber panda, textured for sore gums, with no plastic, no silicone, and - crucially - no sealed water or gel pocket to puncture and leak. Solid rubber, so it also avoids the hollow-toy mold trap if you keep it dry. The soft, chewable plastic-free teether most babies actually take to.
Raw, completely untreated maple rings - no oil, wax, paint, or coating, so the only thing in baby's mouth is bare wood. Plastic-free, silicone- free, AND rubber-free, so it is the pick for a latex-allergic baby or anyone avoiding rubber. Just respect the care rules: wipe dry, never soak or dishwasher untreated wood.
Considered, but not picked
Popular options that look plastic-free but aren't — and why.
Philips Avent (Ultra Soft / Ultra Air) pacifiers
The mainstream default, and the clearest illustration of the shield problem: the nipple is food-grade silicone but the shield is hard plastic (polypropylene / plant-based hard plastic). So even the "soft" premium lines pair a silicone nipple with a plastic shield pressed against the baby's face for hours. Fine for many parents, but neither plastic-free nor silicone-free - the one-piece natural rubber picks avoid both.
MAM pacifiers
Same construction as most mainstream pacifiers - a silicone (or on some lines latex) nipple mounted in a hard plastic shield and button. The shield and handle are plastic in constant contact with the face and mouth. Popular and well-designed, but not plastic-free; a one-piece natural rubber pacifier removes the plastic entirely.
Water- / gel-filled plastic teethers
The chillable "fill and freeze" teethers are a sealed plastic (often soft PVC-type) skin around a water or gel core. The whole chewing surface is plastic, and a punctured or worn seam can leak the fill - the opposite of what you want in a baby's mouth for hours. A solid natural rubber or untreated wood teether gives the chew without the plastic or the leak risk.
Sophie la Girafe
Genuinely 100% natural rubber - but it is coated in food-grade paint and, more importantly, has a single valve hole into a hollow body, which lets water and saliva get sucked inside and has produced widely reported interior mold. The material is right; the hollow-with-a-hole design is the failure mode. A solid one-piece rubber teether (HEVEA Panda) avoids the internal-moisture trap.
Related: Baby Bottles · Kids Plates & Bowls